Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, family, and—if you’re crafty—an excellent opportunity to turn your creative talents into a seriously profitable side hustle!
Whether you’re an experienced crafter or a newbie looking to break into the market, I’ve compiled a list of the 23 most in-demand (and more importantly, profitable) Thanksgiving crafts to make and sell that are sure to be a hit.
All of these ideas are pulled from Etsy, Pinterest & Shopify best-selling data.
23 Thanksgiving Crafts to Make that Sell Like Crazy Online
1) Thanksgiving Wreaths
Wreaths are always popular during the holiday season, and Thanksgiving is no exception.
Create wreaths using autumnal colors, leaves, pinecones, and berries for a festive and inviting front door decoration.
You can even add mini pumpkins, burlap bows, and personalized wooden signs for an extra touch.
- Sell For: $35 – $75 Each
2) Personalized Thanksgiving Table Runners
Personalized table runners make any Thanksgiving table look elegant and put-together.
Offer custom options where customers can add their family’s name or a favorite Thanksgiving quote.
Opt for fall-themed designs, using fabric paints, stencils, or embroidery.
- Sell For: $30 – $60 Each
Related: 19 Sewing Crafts that Sell Like Crazy Online (That Even Beginners Can Make!)
3) Hand-Painted Mason Jar Candle Holders
Mason jars are versatile and can be transformed into beautiful Thanksgiving candle holders.
Paint them with fall colors, add some twine or burlap, and they become the perfect addition to any Thanksgiving table or mantle.
You can even offer scented candles inside for a cozy holiday vibe.
- Sell For: $10 – $25 Each
4) Thanksgiving-Themed Wood Signs
Wood signs with quotes like “Give Thanks” or “Grateful, Thankful, Blessed” are popular Thanksgiving décor pieces.
You can create rustic, farmhouse-style signs by painting or using vinyl lettering on reclaimed wood. These are perfect for both indoor and outdoor use.
- Sell For: $25 – $50 Each
Related: Woodworking Projects That Sell: 19 Most Profitable Ideas
5) Handmade Pumpkin Coasters
Coasters are a practical and fun Thanksgiving craft to make and sell.
Create pumpkin-shaped coasters from cork, felt, or fabric, and offer sets of four or six.
People love functional items that also add a touch of holiday spirit to their home.
- Sell For: $15 – $30 Per Set
Related: 19 Resin Crafts to Make That Sell Like Crazy Online
6) Thanksgiving Centerpieces
Centerpieces are a must-have for any Thanksgiving table, and they can range from simple to elaborate.
Consider making centerpieces with artificial pumpkins, fall flowers, candles, and greenery.
You can also offer custom arrangements based on specific color schemes.
- Sell For: $40 – $100 Per Set
Related: 19 In Demand Needlework Crafts That Sell Like Crazy Online
7) Turkey Wine Glass Charms
Wine glass charms shaped like turkeys or fall leaves are a fun addition to any Thanksgiving gathering.
Create charms using wire, beads, and small trinkets that can easily attach to wine glasses.
These are great stocking-stuffer-style items that sell quickly.
- Sell For: $10 – $20 Per Set
Related: 29 Easy Make Christmas Crafts That Sell Like Crazy
8) Crocheted or Knitted Pumpkins
Handmade, soft crocheted or knitted pumpkins are adorable fall décor items.
You can create them in a variety of colors and sizes, offering a cozy, handmade feel to any Thanksgiving display.
They’re also great for kids’ rooms or living areas.
- Sell For: $15 – $40 Each
Related: 21 In Demand Crochet Crafts That Sell Like Crazy Online
9) Personalized Thanksgiving Place Cards
Personalized place cards make Thanksgiving dinner feel special.
Offer custom designs where customers can choose the names, font style, and colors.
Use cardstock, calligraphy, or even small wooden plaques to make these items truly unique.
- Sell For: $10 – $25 Per Set
Related: 23 Most In Demand Paper Crafts that Sell Like Crazy Online
10) Autumn Leaf Garland
Garlands are a festive way to decorate for the holidays, and an autumn leaf garland is no exception.
Use felt, fabric, or paper to create strings of colorful fall leaves.
These garlands can be hung across mantles, windows, or doorways for a festive touch.
- Sell For: $15 – $35 Each
11) Gratitude Jars
Encourage people to reflect on what they’re thankful for by creating gratitude jars.
You can decorate mason jars with Thanksgiving themes and include small notepads for writing down gratitude notes.
These make thoughtful and meaningful gifts.
- Sell For: $15 – $30 Each
12) Pumpkin Spice Bath Bombs
Everyone loves a good bath bomb, especially during the cozy fall season.
Create bath bombs with a pumpkin spice scent and package them in cute fall-themed boxes.
These are perfect for holiday self-care or gifting to loved ones.
- Sell For: $5 – $10 Each
Related: Best Things to Sell on Etsy To Make a Ton of Money ($5,000+ a Month!)
13) Thanksgiving Napkin Rings
Napkin rings are small but mighty when it comes to Thanksgiving décor.
Make unique, handcrafted napkin rings using materials like burlap, wire, wood beads, or even small turkey figurines.
Offer sets of four or six for customers looking to spruce up their dinner table.
- Sell For: $15 – $30 Per Set
14) Hand-Painted Thanksgiving Mugs
Everyone loves a festive mug to drink their hot cocoa, coffee, or tea during the fall.
Hand-paint mugs with Thanksgiving designs like pumpkins, turkeys, or quotes like “Gobble ‘Til You Wobble.”
These are always popular as gifts or for personal use.
- Sell For: $15 – $30 Each
Related: 21 In-Demand Pottery Crafts That Sell Like Crazy Online
15) Fall-Themed Pillows
Pillows are a great way to change up home décor for the holidays.
Create fall-themed throw pillows using fabrics with pumpkin, leaf, or turkey patterns.
You can also offer personalized options for customers who want to add a family name or a special Thanksgiving message.
- Sell For: $25 – $50 Each
16) Thanksgiving-Themed Mason Jar Recipe Kits
Layered mason jar recipe kits are a fun and easy gift idea that also sells well.
Fill mason jars with the dry ingredients needed to make things like Thanksgiving cookies, pumpkin bread, or cornbread stuffing.
Include a recipe card and decorate the jars with a festive ribbon.
- Sell For: $10 – $25 Each
17) Thanksgiving Gnomes
Gnomes are a trendy décor item, and creating Thanksgiving-themed gnomes can be a hit.
Use felt, fabric, and faux fur to make cute little gnomes with autumnal colors, and add Thanksgiving-themed details like pumpkins, mini cornucopias, or turkey hats.
- Sell For: $15 – $40 Each
Related: 24 Best Easy Things to Make and Sell Online For Extra Money
18) Turkey Feather Headbands
For those hosting or attending Thanksgiving with kids, turkey feather headbands are a fun craft that will sell like crazy.
These cute headbands can be made from felt or paper feathers and sold as party favors or kid-friendly costume accessories.
- Sell For: $5 – $15 Each
19) Handmade Thanksgiving Cards
Handmade cards are always popular during the holiday season.
Create beautiful, hand-painted or hand-stamped Thanksgiving cards featuring turkeys, fall leaves, or pumpkins.
Offer a variety of designs and even the option for customers to personalize the inside message.
- Sell For: $5 – $10 Each
Related: How to Make Stickers to Sell Online (Even if You Can’t Draw!)
20) Wood-Burned Cheese Boards
Cheese boards are a Thanksgiving staple, and wood-burned boards with fall-themed designs or personalized names make them extra special.
Using a wood-burning tool, you can create intricate designs on wooden boards, adding a handmade touch that elevates the holiday experience.
- Sell For: $25 – $50 Each
21) Pumpkin Spice Candles
Nothing says fall like the scent of pumpkin spice.
Make your own candles using soy wax and pumpkin spice fragrance, and pour them into cute mason jars or decorative tins.
Add labels with Thanksgiving designs to make them extra appealing to customers.
- Sell For: $10 – $20 Each
22) Handcrafted Cornucopias
Cornucopias are a traditional Thanksgiving symbol, representing abundance and gratitude.
Create handcrafted cornucopias using natural materials like wicker, raffia, and dried fruits.
These make beautiful centerpieces or thoughtful gifts.
- Sell For: $40 – $75 Each
23) Thanksgiving-Themed Tote Bags
Reusable tote bags are both eco-friendly and practical.
Create Thanksgiving-themed tote bags using fabric paint, screen printing, or heat transfer vinyl.
Add fun phrases like “Give Thanks” or “Feast Mode” alongside seasonal imagery.
- Sell For: $10 – $25 Each
Selling Tips to Maximize Your Thanksgiving Craft Profits
Now that you have plenty of craft ideas, it’s important to know how to sell them effectively.
Here are a few tips to help you boost your sales during the Thanksgiving season:
1) Market Early: Don’t wait until the last minute to start promoting your Thanksgiving crafts. Start marketing them a month or two in advance so customers have time to order before the holiday.
2) Use Social Media: Platforms like Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook are great places to showcase your crafts. Use high-quality photos, engaging captions, and hashtags to reach your audience.
3) Offer Customization: Customers love personalized items, so consider offering customization options, whether it’s adding a name, date, or personal message.
4) Bundle Products: Create bundles of related items to encourage customers to buy more. For example, bundle Thanksgiving wreaths with matching table centerpieces or place cards with napkin rings.
5) Host a Pop-Up Shop: If you’re selling locally, consider hosting a pop-up shop at a farmers market, craft fair, or even partnering with local businesses to display your Thanksgiving crafts.
6) Create Gift Sets: Thanksgiving crafts can make great gifts. Put together gift sets, like a hand-painted mug with a Thanksgiving card or a candle with a matching centerpiece.
